Pittsburgh, PA

Marburger Farm Dairy
Starting with the purchase of one hundred acres of land in Evans City, PA, Marburger Farm Dairy is a fifth generation, family-owned farm that has been operating in one form or another since 1842. Raising cows that produce hormone and rBST-free milk, you can imagine how natural and flavorful their eggnog is! With a distinctly fresh quality and just the right amount of holiday spice (nutmeg!), each sip is a celebration!

Cleveland

Hartzler Family Dairy Eggnog
Made with Hartzler whole milk, this eggnog makes a great hostess gift for parties or a nice little treat to tuck away in the refrigerator for yourself after a long night of holiday card mailing, if you still do that kind of thing. Packaged in a newly designed and dated quart bottle each year, it’s always especially old-fashioned. Enjoy straight up, in your coffee or as a nightcap with rum.. It also makes amazing eggnog cookies — we know!

Columbus

Snowville Creamery Grass-Fed Dairy Products
Owned by Warren and Victoria Taylor and located in Pomeroy, OH, everything that Snowville Creamery makes is made with milk from independently owned Hamm Valley Farms and The Brick Dairy Farm, home to herds of grass-fed cattle. This may not sound like much, but is actually quite important. Grass-fed cows essentially have an all-natural diet, which improves their physical fitness, and it’s also good for the environment. More importantly, Snowville Creamery cows are raised without the use of rBST (artificial bovine growth hormones) and the milk is not homogenized, so the cream rises to the top. This holiday season, try Snowville Creamy eggnog. It’s all that and more!

Indianapolis

Oberweis Dairy Eggnog
Family farms feed their own loved ones the same milk and dairy that's produced for their customers, and Oberweis Dairy is just that: a family farm. Not only is their milk the a wholesome family favorite, but their eggnog, which is made with their milk, reflects a generational pride in an annual, beloved holiday tradition. Rich and creamy and spiced just right, Oberwies eggnog makes family festivities that much more … um, festive!